Review 3369

The title, “Where We Relax,” in the author’s self-appointed category, “Personal,” suggests this might be a family blog, about the places two or more people who spend a lot of time together go to relax. I imagined parks, saunas, swimming pools, cafes, most of them kid-friendly, illustrated with photos of the happy group enjoying their sojourn from the nine to five. It would be bursting with “awww” moments and the scent of fresh air so tactile it would cause tendrils of longing and envy as the reader dreamed of escaping from behind the computer screen into a playground of green earth, dirt, dandelions, and buggy-wugs. Naturally, reality bears no resemblance to my imagination. Normally I cope with the stress of this rift by eating cookies and reading surrealist fiction. The bloggers over at “Where We Relax” suggest that I cope with that stress by using one of their massage products, available through their sponsor, Ultimate Water Massage.

The blog is written by a team of seven people. Thus far most entries have been written by the only two without human names, Service Guru and Product Guru. In lieu of an “About,” one must refer to the upper toolbar and select “Company and Authors,” which is a blog post written by Admin, which is either short for “administrator” or the name of a human male. Here one learns that the blog is written by employees. For once my imagination isn’t concussed after colliding with reality.

The design is based on the idea of water. The background is a soothing collage of blue abstract shapes and lines. The entries and navigation column are silver with rounded edges, while the content background baby blue framed by lavender. Very feng shui.

Aside from a smattering of first person posts that begin with the story of a stressful meeting or painful toe and end with sweet relief offered by one of the company’s products, most of the blog entries are decidedly impersonal. Strangely, the topics that have the most posts seem to have the blog writers as the intended audience. “Writers Only” and “Writing for WordPress Tips” have a combined total of 15 posts, balanced against 23 posts under the 8 other categories combined.

Most of the other posts are about stress, ways people cope with it, what causes it, the damage it can do, and concerns along those lines. The posts read like professional articles, which is to say, they are very well written. Many are punctuated with statistics and polls. According to one of the how-to-write posts, this is the “E” in a SUPER post. A SUPER post is Simple, Unexpected, Practical, Expert, and Relates to the reader. Wedged between the E and R of a SUPER post, one learns that Expertise, specifically when the reader perceives it, DEFEATS doubt. How can you be sure the reader perceives your expertise? By using Demonstrations, Examples, Facts, Evidence, Analogy, Testimonials, and Statistics, one can be sure to bludgeon doubt by exuding the perception of expertise.

As a reader, any one of those letters might dispel doubt, but when they are all used in a cacophony, what is perceived is not expertise but the salesman’s pitch. Bites of numbers and percentages don’t necessarily lend credibility, especially when one doesn’t know where the numbers came from, how they were counted, or who counted them. Statistics are notorious for being misleading, and statistically, people are disinclined to follow things that will mislead them.

The writers are knowledgeable and skilled at crafting technical essays. However, I can’t shake the feeling that it’s all crafted just to sell something to me. This blog doesn’t seem to have found its own voice yet. Normally I have no problem imagining what kind of person might read a particular blog on a regular basis, but aside from repeat customers and industry employees, my imagination fails me. However, the first entry was made less than two months ago, so this blog is young enough to be rife with potential.
NULL

Review 3371

The URL provided for the review sent me to a Disney Family website. At first evaluation, I didn’t see a blog, I saw a Disney website filled with Disney movies and Disney products, but no Blog.

The “blogging” section was “below the fold” to use an old newsprint term, and is also not included in the top level navigation bar of the site. Determined to quash this as a non-blog website so I didn’t have to review it, I dug around on the front page and saw the “Family Bloggers” section of the site, down in the bottom right hand corner of the page. The header of the site states it is a production in Beta, so I would suggest that if they want people to read their collection of blogs, they should include them in the top level navigation bar as an option. Not just on the “parenting” page including a link to one blog, and the “food” page a link to another… and so on and so on…

For the record, the blogging collective is housed at http://family.go.com/blog and this is the section of the site I will review.

The “Disney Family Bloggers” page is prefaced by the following: “Family life can be frenzied, challenging, and anxiety-provoking but also hilarious, rewarding, and exhilarating. Need proof that you’re not alone? Get to know the Disney Family Bloggers.”

These Family Bloggers are a hoard of 19 “types” of parents. Nineteen. Not African American, one of them is Asian, and only two of them are male.

And the bloggers don’t come off as individuals, they come off as Jungian Archetypes of Parents. There is Professor Mom, Fit Mom, Tri-athlete Mom, Sitting On The Couch Mom, Slacker Lookin’ Dad (who after reading his blog I find out he’s not a dad at all, see below…), Likes To Cook Dad, Shopper Mom, Travelin’ Mom, Ready To Drop Daughter Deuce Mom, Mom of Twins Mom. I guess we’re trying to cover all the parenting types in one place.

The profile photos and short bios mostly made me cringe a little. I felt I didn’t relate to a single one of these people even though Disney has gone to great lengths to find a what they believe is diverse collection of bloggers. In looking at all the profiles, I found that I was only remotely interested in three of the parenting types. The Travelin’ Mom and the Sittin on the Couch Mom, and the Slacker Lookin’ Dad (who turns out not to be a dad at all, see below).

I dug most deeply into the following. Mother_Road who writes “Kid Trippin'”, ThompsonClanMom who writes “Posts from the Couch” and Sweaterhead who writes “The Village Tweed.”

Starting with the Travelin’ Mom, I found her to be more of a journalist than a blogger, and that is exactly what she is. She’s a journalist, and all her archives read like articles for tour guides, not really about “traveling with kids” with anecdotes and stories of misadventure and mayhem from the blue highways that gird our nation. Kid Trippin’ turns out to be advice for parents looking for suggestions for places to go with the kids. Mother_Road recommends places like London and Florida, Downeast Maine and what to do Indoors and Outdoors with your kids all the place. It read more like the Frommer’s Guide that she references more than once, and I found it to be boring. My high-hopes were shattered. Yawn.

Moving on to ThompsonClanMom who writes her Posts from the Couch, we find a woman who hates last minute play dates, all the begging for money her kids’ school keeps doing, bad nutrition choices, the sexy allure of the scent of coffee, how her kids love Disney Princess movies and the songs get stuck in her head… even when she writes about how she loses her mind and screams at the kids for running late and not wanting to go to school, it feels empty and sterilized and not very authentic. I left this blog bored as well.

On to the Sweaterhead, who is Jared from Brooklyn and is a knitter. The Village Tweed is his blog, and he writes about yarn and knitting. I had hoped that in addition to knitting he’d be a little more Bohemian and fun… but he writes about knitting. And when that’s your passion it’s okay. But again, the coolest LOOKING profile with the most potential, I left disappointed. The thing I noticed was that in none of his entries did he mention his own children, just knitting, yarn, making sweaters for babies and more knitting. And that’s because, as he confesses… “Now, I’m not a parent and I don’t claim to understand all that goes in to parenting…”

I don’t get it. How is he included as a family blogger? Aren’t there some Daddy blogs or Grandpa Blogs our Expectant Father Blogs out there?

This website pretty much typifies why I hate most of what Disney puts out into the world. Princesses and Fantasies, no real substance or “diversity” represented even among 19 humans… men who knit included because what, that’s safe and kitchy and cute, instead of Dads who work their butts off and come home and put their feet up with a beer and blog about what a cruddy day it was and how hard it was to come home. Cookie Cutter types of moms, and every single one of the 19 blogs has exactly 8 pages of archives. Are they all blogging on schedule? Like a blogging mill? It was kind of creepy and disconcerting.

As mentioned, the entire collection of bloggers is headed up with “Family life can be frenzied, challenging, and anxiety-provoking but also hilarious, rewarding, and exhilarating…” And to be honest, I found absolutely none of that inside the collective of bloggers. No real hilarity, no real frenzy, nothing exhilarating.

I hated this website and plan never to return. You may like it if you’re looking for the Disnification of Blogging… the Vanilla and the Pedestrian. The typical American non-edgey, pre-packaged shrink-wrapped, non-reality of it all. I’m not. There are so many better parenting sites out there, written by individuals and collectives of parents who produce content together, who are far more genuine and interesting, compelling and fascinating. They don’t review products like Bounty Paper Towels or recommend you take your kid to theme amusement parks on vacation.

Feh. Now I’m off to ride bikes with my kids and pray to the blogging gods that I never become a Disney Blogger archetype.

NULL

Review 3364

Unique South America Travel Experience is not really a blog, but I felt the need to review it because I feel the website owner truly loves his subject.

The site is filled with photographs and personal remembrances by a traveler who has been to South America, and writes in his “About Us” that he is in Dublin Ireland (a place I personally long to visit) and will one day return to his beloved continent. The About Us page does not let us know who the author is, aside from a photo at the top of the page which I presume is our author. I’ve guessed that the website owner is one “Daniel Moore,” because several of the photos on the site are attributed to that individual. I would recommend editing the About Us page to make it clear who is speaking to us and encouraging us to take a chance in visiting South America one day.

From the opening page, the writer makes it clear his love for South America and all the countries therein. There is a date-stamp on the page that shows the current date, but I believe that is code generated and not a sign that the site was updated today. The layout of the Homepage is kind of lumpy, with huge text and lots of pictures and a giant Google Ads box in the middle of things, disturbing the textual flow of the page.

The navigation on the left sidebar makes has a nice natural flow, and the only thing I’d recommend is moving the About Us page up to the second position. The navigation is repeated at the bottom of each of the webpages, which is redundant and should be removed.

The next option in the navigation is SA Travel Blog which offers readers an RSS option for when the blog is updated, but there isn’t any “blog” content.

Moving on from the blog and the overview of the continent on the first page, we move country by country through South America. Here is where the true heart of the site lies. The author writes about each country and top destinations, and the sometimes scary adventures he had in each nation.

While interesting to read about things he experienced from the 1970s onward, I found this to be a site that I won’t necessarily visit again… unless I need maps. I would suggest our author update more frequently, perhaps use Blogger or something to actually BLOG about his travels, and I truly hope he makes it back to his beloved South America someday. Ireland may be lovely, but the photos of SA make it look dreary and boring in comparison.

I give this site a 2.75 rating, as it is worth a look once, but doesn’t generate a desire for anyone to really revisit. NULL

Review 3370

Hip Hop World is a blog that features news on and video from hip hop artists. The site has a black background with white text and yellow navigation in the sidebar, which isn’t as hard on the eyes as I’ve found in the past.

There is no “about” page listed that I could find, no blogger profile. So I am not sure if our author is an American or International Hip Hop fan. An about page is always key, so we know the profile of the writer and where he or she is coming from. I suggest activating that in the blogger dashboard so we know more about the person taking the time to bring us the news.

The standard three column blogger template is deployed but is slightly out of skew. The header banner (at 804px wide) is too big for the table, and hangs out of the table frame to the right by about fiddy pixels. Because the table is the wrong size for the content, the right navigation column is forced to the bottom of the screen for users at 1024×768 resolution. (I viewed the site on my monitor at home and at work with the same problem).

Seeing as the right panel navigation is incredibly important, I would suggest to the blogger that the size of the table be increased, or size of the photos and videos inside the center column be decreased. A little bit of code-tweaking can fix this problem quickly, and can be done through the blogger dashboard.

The left navigation bar has icons for going straight to iTunes to buy certain artists’ latest recordings. There is a message board to dialog with other Hip Hop fans, which opens up discourse and interaction with a wider community. Unfortunately, the site is too young for that feature to really have gotten off the ground at this point, but I think that if the blog author gets a little more exposure the community can grow.

There are few archives to the site at this point, just April to June. This was just enough content to keep me reading and interested this morning. Also, the site categories are listed out by artist, so if you’re only interested in Ciara or Timbaland, you can go to those categories and read the entries for your favorite artist.

My favorite part of the blog was the biographies, which sound like they were written by the author and not creatively appropriated from Wikipedia or another source. I also loved the header graphic, which is a beautiful mural portrait of hip hop’s current and past, living and gone, performers.

My major complaint with the site, aside from the layout being messed up with the right panel navigation forced to the bottom of the screen, is the overwhelming amount of Ads by Google content. Under the header, in the left side panel, and after every single entry… Way way way too much. The target audience is more interested in reading about hip hop and less interested in the advertising. I know everyone is trying to make money off the web in whatever way they can, but I’d totally pare down on the advertising… at the header of the page and in the entries. Leave the Ads by Google in the left panel of the site, away from the content.

I give the site a 3 rating, because I see potential as it grows. Now, where’s the review on the Beastie Boys’ new release. Rolling Stone says it’s the best ever.NULL

Review 3375

According to his profile, Gary, or GMan1948, our blog author, has worn many “hats” over the years. He is a “semi-retired” CEO and bookseller.

The first thing that happened when I clicked on the URL to review his site was it crashed my computer.

After rebooting my system, I tried again. His blog forced a java update onto my PC, which I totally didn’t like. I use Firefox, so I guess that I wasn’t as up to date as I thought I was. After a few minutes of java updating and another cup of coffee retrieved, the site was loaded and I proceeded to get to work.

The top of the page under the blogger banner has six banner sized news and advertisement bars and a small calendar navigation box to the right for his blog content. The news and advertising banners weren’t interesting to me, so I began to scroll down the page. I scrolled down past articles about marketing and articles about advertising. I encountered his profile on the right sidebar, and more news and more advertising in the main part of the blog. Good grief, where is the content? More ads! eBay! Dell! Amazon! Blog Blaster!

Finally, an entry. It was dated recently, so I knew this wasn’t a shell of a site to click through for ad revenue, Gary’s content began more than halfway down the blog.

You know what my criticism is here, don’t you? One shouldn’t have to scroll until one’s fingers ache to get to blog content. The sad thing is, all that scrolling was for naught. The blog content wasn’t all that thrilling, and quite a let-down since I had to dig for it so deeply. Gary blogs other people’s content, about microbusiness, launching websites for small businesses, and how to make money with your blog.

Blogvermercial indeed.

The only saving grace is that he actually attributes sourcing to the authors of the articles he quotes extensively or reprints in total. How incredibly refreshing! I have reviewed blogs here on Weblog Review where the content is obviously lifted from other sources and the blogger NEVER links back or attributes ownership. So it was nice to see actual “about the author” information on each of the entries for the past several months.

The site archives go back to February 2006, and it was only by going back there did I find any content written by the blogger himself, from his opinion and position. Commercials he hates, commercials he loves, how he used Craigslist and wanted to know what other people thought about bartering.

That’s a blog. Interesting,

The past couple of months worth of entries are simply cut and paste reposts of other articles. I think Gary’s blog, opinions and voice have been eaten alive by the concepts of advertising and marketing on the web. And this is really sad, because I bet Gary has some great stories, anecdotes about customer service and business, and opinions that are better than what he is culling and pasting from the web.

That’s something that happens in our modern consumer culture. And it is kind of sad because I enjoyed reading the early months of the blog.

In short — the ads and all the noise at the top of the page totally detract from the site, and the author is lost. I give the site a 2. I see hope and potential if Gary gets back to writing and speaking his own voice instead of letting other articles fill the space. Hopefully he will. He has two other blogs in his Technorati profile, so perhaps those spots are where he shines. I’ll have to visit and see… but right here at the Blogvermercial? Not so much.

NULL